Validity of Jurisdiction Agreements in GT&Cs

Benn-Ibler Rechtsanwälte

The Austrian Supreme Court (Oberster Gerichtshof, hereinafter OGH) considered the question of the conditions under which a jurisdiction agreement in a company’s general terms and conditions is validly concluded if a contracting party’s order deviates from the original offer.

Dispute over jurisdiction agreement

The plaintiff, a limited partnership, had asserted a claim against a German GmbH in the amount of around EUR 108,262.The dispute concerned whether the validity of an agreement conferring jurisdiction agreement was valid under Article 25 of the Brussels I Regulation.

The plaintiff had submitted an offer to the defendant on 25 October 2023 with a covering letter referring to the applicable General Terms and Conditions of Sale and Delivery, which also contained a jurisdiction clause. Following further contract negotiations, the plaintiff submitted a new offer on 26 April 2024 and again referred to those these conditions.

On 31 May 2024, the defendant submitted an order in which the defendant expressly referred to the plaintiff's offer of 26 April 2024. However, the order contained divergent quantities and prices.

The defendant disputed the validity of the jurisdiction agreement

The defendant questioned the validity of the jurisdiction agreement. In particular, the defendant argued that the appointment had contained numerous deviations from the plaintiff's offer and had also been made ‘without obligation’.

The court of appeal deemed this to be an effective jurisdiction clause.

OGH: Reference to general terms and conditions is sufficient

The OGH reiterated that the written-form requirement ensures that the jurisdiction agreement is clearly established and does not become part of the contract unnoticed. This requirement is met if the contract expressly refers to general terms and conditions containing a jurisdiction clause. It is also met if the contract clearly refers to an offer that expressly refers to such terms, provided the other party actually received them together with the offer. Excessive formalism incompatible within business must be avoided. 

The OGH noted that the defendant had not simply made a counteroffer but had expressly referred in their order to the plaintiff’s offer and, by extension, thus also to the general terms and conditions that had been transmitted several times.

The assumption of an effective jurisdiction agreement by the court of appeal thus remained valid.

OGH 1Ob 79/26p (24 June 2026)




More Services